Dive Brief:
- The Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures is calling on the International Sustainability Standards Board to create a mandatory standard for companies to disclose biodiversity and other risks, rather than a voluntary practice statement like ISSB proposed last month.
- TNFD — which provides a global framework that helps companies and financial institutions manage and report nature-related risks and impacts — made the ask in a comment letter on Tuesday, after ISSB opened its proposal for public feedback. “The TNFD believes that, on balance, a better outcome for report preparers and report users is for the ISSB to produce a Sustainability Standard on nature-related disclosures in the form of a Standard,” the letter said.
- TNFD is not the first group to push back on the nonmandatory nature of ISSB’s first proposal. Shortly after the initial proposal was released, a group of financial institutions organized under the Finance for Biodiversity Foundation also called for the disclosures to be issued in the form of a standard.
Dive Insight:
ISSB, which operates under the International Financial Reporting Standards Foundation, said its proposed voluntary practice statement for corporate nature-related disclosures drew “extensively” on TNFD’s prior work. TNFD was launched in 2021 and worked for two years to develop nature-related disclosure recommendations; last year, ISSB announced it would take up TNFD’s work in a move welcomed by the task force.’
TNFD said in its Nov. 17 comment letter that it recognizes that one of the ISSB standards, the IFRS S1, requires companies to disclose material nature-related risks and opportunities and the contents of a practice statement can “be the same as a standard.” However, it said there is a “critical difference between an IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standard and a Practice Statement for reporting entities.”
The nature-focused group said a standard would be preferred over a voluntary practice statement because it would create “a global baseline” for market participants; send a stronger signal “about the evidence of the materiality of information about nature-related risks and opportunities;” and help governments meet policy commitments on biodiversity. Additionally, the group said a standard would benefit from the ecosystem’s familiarity and understanding of ISSB standards, as opposed to practice statements.
An ISSB standard on disclosure of nature-related risks and opportunities would “deliver the level playing field that reporting entities want, and the consistent, comparable and decision-useful information that investors and other primary users need,” TNFD said in a Tuesday press release announcing its comment letter.
ISSB’s draft practice statement included how companies should disclose how they are responding to nature-related risks, including how they plan to meet any related targets they have set or are required to set by law. This includes any current or anticipated changes to an entity’s business model or current and anticipated efforts to mitigate and adapt to a changing availability or affordability of environmental resources, according to the draft disclosure.
In addition to recommending that the standard be mandatory, TNFD’s letter also recommends the standard-setter provide an effective date for the disclosures. An effective date for the disclosures would give “reporting entities and jurisdictions sufficient time to prepare and a clear implementation pathway” and also help avoid disruptions to jurisdictions implementing ISSB’s climate-risk disclosure standards, TNFD said.
There are over 36 global jurisdictions that have implemented or are implementing ISSB’s IFRS S1 and S2 disclosure standards, according to IFRS.
“Consistent global reporting on nature is critical because the resilience of every business and every investment portfolio depends on nature – across all sectors and all geographies,” TNFD said in the release.
TNFD said in its comment letter that it welcomed the proposal — which ISSB is seeking comments on until Feb. 19, 2027 — and its “strong alignment” with TNFD’s prior work and recommendations. The group said in the release that ISSB’s work on the topic is “a critical step for shifting the mindset across business and finance about the resilience of their business and its dependence on the resilience [of] nature.”